The Future of Learning and Development: Why Critical Thinking and Business Acumen Matter More Than Ever with Shana Storey

Generative AI is changing how learning and development teams create content, support employees, and respond to business needs. Tasks that once required months of development can now be accomplished much faster. But as technology takes on more of the production work, what skills will distinguish successful L&D professionals?

For Shana Storey, Vice President of Talent Development and Organizational Effectiveness, the answer isn’t simply becoming more proficient with AI tools. It’s developing the critical thinking, adaptability, and business understanding needed to solve the right problems.

In this episode of TrainingPros’ Learning Leader Spotlight, Shana joins guest host Kelley Kalbas to explore how L&D is evolving, why performance consulting is becoming increasingly important, and what learning leaders should prioritize as they prepare their teams for the future.

What Skills Will L&D Professionals Need
as AI Transforms Learning and Development?

Quick Answer: 

As AI takes on more learning content development and performance support tasks, L&D professionals will need stronger critical thinking, adaptability, and business acumen. Shana Storey emphasizes that technical skills can be learned, but the ability to ask thoughtful questions, evaluate AI-generated outputs, understand organizational challenges, and help people navigate change will become increasingly valuable. These capabilities position L&D professionals as strategic business partners rather than content producers.

What You’ll Learn:

  • How generative AI is making personalized learning and performance support more practical.
  • Why L&D teams are shifting from content development toward performance consulting.
  • Which human capabilities will become more important as AI tools advance.
  • How AI coaching and human mentorship can complement each other.
  • Why understanding business operations is essential for advancing into L&D leadership.

AI Is Finally Making Learning at
the Moment of Need More Practical

For decades, L&D professionals have discussed personalized learning and performance support. The goal has been to give employees the right guidance when they need it, rather than expecting them to remember everything from a training program.

Shana sees generative AI as an important turning point in making that vision achievable.

She references Bob Mosher’s Five Moments of Need framework and describes how AI-powered tools can provide support within existing workflows. Instead of requiring a major technology implementation, L&D teams can now build custom GPTs or coaching tools that address specific performance needs.

A solution that might previously have taken months to develop can potentially be created much more quickly.

This changes the possibilities for L&D teams, particularly those working with limited resources. Instead of building an entire course to address every possible question, learning professionals can explore ways to provide guidance at the moment an employee needs help.

However, Shana also acknowledges a practical limitation. Not every organization can adopt these tools freely. Compliance requirements, technology restrictions, and organizational policies can prevent L&D teams from using the latest AI capabilities.

For learning leaders, the opportunity is to identify where AI can genuinely improve employee performance while working within the organization’s technology and governance requirements.

From Content Development to Performance Consulting

As AI accelerates content production and organizations look for ways to accomplish more with fewer resources, Shana believes L&D teams have an opportunity to reconsider where they contribute the most value.

Rather than concentrating primarily on creating courses, L&D professionals can become more involved in understanding organizational challenges and helping people adapt to change.

Shana describes an approach that has shaped her career: getting involved in major organizational change initiatives as a business partner rather than waiting for someone to request training.

When a stakeholder comes to L&D asking for a course, the more valuable starting point may be understanding the problem the stakeholder is trying to solve. This is also where Shana sees the profession heading.

Organizations have access to extensive off-the-shelf learning content, and AI is making additional content easier to create. That allows internal L&D teams to spend more time curating experiences, consulting with stakeholders, and addressing broader talent and performance challenges.

Looking Beyond the Training Request

Shana suggests that L&D’s role may increasingly extend into talent consulting, where learning professionals consider how employee capabilities, organizational change, and business needs connect.

That requires understanding more than instructional design principles. Learning professionals need to recognize how work gets done, what challenges employees face, and what organizational outcomes stakeholders are trying to achieve.

For L&D leaders, this raises an important question: Are team members spending most of their time producing learning deliverables, or are they helping determine which interventions will actually improve performance? The answer can influence how leaders structure their teams, develop their people, and prioritize future investments.

Critical Thinking and Agility Are
More Important Than Any Single Technical Skill

When Kelley asks which skills are most important for L&D professionals today, Shana doesn’t name a particular technology, platform, or development tool. Instead, she identifies two capabilities: agility and critical thinking. Technical skills can be learned as new tools emerge. Mindset, resilience, and the ability to adapt are harder to develop quickly. These capabilities become especially important when working with generative AI.

AI can produce a polished-looking learning solution in seconds. But someone still needs to determine whether that solution addresses the right problem, is appropriate for the audience, and contains accurate information.

As Shana explains: “If you don’t have good critical thinking skills, how are you going to know what your output is giving you is right for the audience or right for the problem?” Without that judgment, L&D professionals risk using AI to produce more content without improving its quality or relevance.

What This Means for L&D Teams

For learning leaders, developing AI proficiency shouldn’t stop at teaching employees how to use prompts or generate materials. Team members also need opportunities to practice evaluating outputs, questioning assumptions, and connecting learning recommendations to business needs.

For example, an AI tool might generate a complete onboarding course from existing documentation. An experienced learning professional still needs to determine whether the documentation reflects how employees actually perform the work, where new hires struggle, and whether a course is the appropriate intervention.

The ability to make those decisions is what turns AI-generated content into a useful performance solution.

Listen around 12:26 as Shana explains why critical thinking and adaptability are the skills she would prioritize over technical expertise.

AI Can Support Coaching,
but Human Mentorship Still Matters

One of the more interesting distinctions in the conversation is Shana’s perspective on how AI and human mentorship can work together. She sees AI-powered coaching as a useful resource for routine questions and day-to-day learning needs. Employees can use AI to explore unfamiliar concepts, ask questions, and receive personalized guidance. But she doesn’t see that as eliminating the need for human mentors. Instead, it may allow mentorship relationships to focus on something AI cannot fully provide: the context of working within a particular organization.

A mentor can help someone understand organizational dynamics, navigate relationships, recognize unwritten expectations, and make decisions informed by experience. This becomes especially important for employees beginning their careers in remote environments.

Shana recognizes how difficult it can be for someone entering the workforce without regular opportunities to observe colleagues, develop relationships, and learn how an organization operates. She encourages professionals at every career stage to seek projects that expose them to different mentors and perspectives.

Mentorship Also Shapes How Leaders Lead

Shana shares how an early mentor, Murray Christensen, influenced her approach to leadership. When she was a new manager, Murray encouraged her to think more broadly about data analytics, stakeholder needs, and the impact of learning solutions. Rather than directing every decision, he helped her develop new perspectives. That experience continues to influence how she leads teams.

She describes a collaborative leadership philosophy that makes room for contributions from employees at different career stages, rather than assuming the most senior person always has the best perspective.

For learning leaders designing development programs, the implication is that mentorship should extend beyond formal career advice. It can create opportunities for employees to understand the business, contribute to meaningful projects, and learn from colleagues with different experiences.

The Future of L&D Still Includes Human Connection

Although much of the conversation focuses on AI, Shana doesn’t envision a future in which all learning becomes technology-driven. In fact, she expects human interaction to become even more valuable.

As AI and digital tools make information easier to access, the purpose of live learning experiences may shift. Rather than concentrating on transferring knowledge, these experiences can help people connect ideas, collaborate, and understand how different concepts apply to their work.

Shana specifically mentions instructor-led training and flipped classroom approaches as areas that may become increasingly relevant. The opportunity is to use technology for activities it handles well while reserving human interaction for experiences that benefit from discussion, shared perspectives, and collaboration. She also sees renewed interest in mentorship and apprenticeship programs.

For L&D leaders, this suggests that the future isn’t necessarily about replacing traditional learning modalities with AI. It’s about reconsidering the purpose of each modality and using the right combination to help employees develop and perform.

Business Acumen May Be
the Most Important Investment in an L&D Career

Near the end of the conversation, Kelley asks Shana to recommend a book for professionals aspiring to L&D leadership. Rather than naming one essential book, Shana offers broader career advice: learn how businesses operate.

Learning professionals already spend considerable time studying adult learning theory, instructional methods, and learning technologies. But advancing into leadership requires understanding the issues that matter to business stakeholders.

Shana describes reading about data management because she wants to understand the challenges and perspectives of the people she supports. She also looks beyond traditional L&D sources for professional development, following technology leaders, consulting organizations, and researchers who examine broader business and workforce issues.

Her approach reflects a larger point about professional growth. Learning leaders cannot become effective business partners by studying learning practices alone. They need to understand how their organizations operate, what drives decisions, and how different functions contribute to results.

Reading and professional development can provide valuable perspectives, but Shana emphasizes that conversations with people are equally important. The real value comes from applying what you’ve learned to the challenges facing your organization. For L&D professionals who want to advance into leadership, that may mean spending less time looking for the next learning methodology and more time understanding the business problems their stakeholders are trying to solve.

Trainingpros Rings Tealorange Rgb

Business Metrics Every Instructional Designer Should Know

Free PDF
Trainingpros Rings Tealorange Rgb

Key Takeaways for Learning Leaders

1. Use AI to improve performance, not simply accelerate content production. Explore opportunities for personalized coaching and support at the moment of need.

2. Develop stronger performance consulting capabilities. Help team members investigate business problems before recommending training solutions.

3. Make critical thinking central to AI development. Teach L&D professionals to evaluate outputs, challenge assumptions, and determine whether AI-generated solutions meet actual needs.

4. Combine technology with human mentorship. Use AI for routine guidance while creating opportunities for employees to build relationships and understand organizational context.

5. Build business acumen across the L&D team. Encourage learning professionals to understand the priorities, operations, and challenges of the business functions they support.

Listen to the Full Conversation

Shana Storey brings a practical perspective to the future of learning and development, shaped by her experience leading L&D teams and supporting organizational change. Listen to the full episode of Learning Leader Spotlight to hear her thoughts on AI, the evolving role of learning professionals, mentorship, and what it takes to become a stronger business partner.

Episode Highlights

Timestamp Topic
02:00
Preparing employees for future skills and organizational change
03:48
How a graphic design background led Shana into L&D
06:08
How generative AI is changing personalized learning and performance support
08:14
The shift toward performance consulting and broader talent development
09:14
Why human connection and instructor-led learning remain important
11:29
How AI coaching and human mentorship can complement each other
12:26
Why agility and critical thinking matter more than technical skills
18:59
Why aspiring L&D leaders need to understand how businesses operate

Continue Exploring Learning Leader Episodes

Explore More TrainingPros Resources:

What Is Performance Consulting? A Practical Guide for L&D Leaders

What Is Performance Consulting? A Practical Guide For L&Amp;D Leaders - Trainingpros

Read more here

What Does a Learning Strategist Do? Why Every Learning Initiative Starts with Strategy

What Does A Learning Strategist Do? Why Every Learning Initiative Starts With Strategy - Trainingpros

Read more here

Aligning Learning with Strategy: Business Acumen for L&D Professionals

Aligning Learning With Strategy: Business Acumen For L&Amp;D Professionals - Trainingpros

Read more here

Need Additional Expertise
as Your L&D Team Evolves?

Does your L&D team have more projects than people?

Many organizations reach a point where their existing L&D team is fully occupied designing and delivering learning while strategic decisions continue to pile up. A contract Learning Strategist provides the expertise to align learning with business goals, prioritize initiatives, develop a learning roadmap, and help your organization make confident learning investments without adding a full-time position. Learn how TrainingPros connects organizations with experienced Learning Strategists.

TrainingPros is a learning and development company that connects organizations with experienced instructional designers, contract facilitators, and virtual classroom producers. We’ve been named a Top 20 Staffing Company by Training Industry and a Champion of Learning by the Association for Talent Development (ATD), recognition that reflects our commitment to delivering high-quality, tailored learning solutions.

To hear candid conversations with senior learning leaders, listen to our Learning Leader Spotlight podcast:

Apple | Spotify | YouTube 

If your learning initiatives require additional support, whether for a single project or a large-scale rollout, our relationship managers can help you find the right expertise quickly and confidently.

Join the conversation today! 

When you have more projects than people™, let TrainingPros find the right consultant to start your project with confidence.